Monday, 7 March 2011

Left Out In The Cold - PRESS RELEASE

“We don’t want to be ‘Left Out In The Cold’ ”, say Britain’s disabled people.
On the eve of the second reading of the government’s controversial Welfare Reform Bill on 9th March, a stark image of disabled campaigner Kaliya Franklin aims to convey how vulnerable some of the bills proposals will leave sick and disabled people across the UK.

The photograph depicts a naked Franklin lying on the sand on a wintry beach, next to her empty wheelchair.

Just like Franklin’s wheelchair in the image, social care and support will be left out of reach for many of those most in need if these reforms go ahead, literally leaving many “Left Out in the Cold.”

“We decided to use one thought provoking image to make our point,” explains Franklin. “Sick and disabled people are often left voiceless in society, so we hoped using a single image might reflect this.”

Says Franklin, “It’s vital we all remember we are just an accident or illness away from becoming disabled. Many people think if they do become disabled that the state will look after them.

“But the fact is that even under current provisions, disability benefits are not enough for disabled people to live on. If the Welfare Reform Bill is passed, the situation will become unimaginably worse.”

In January, Franklin released a video on YouTube that explained how able-bodied people would be in for a major shock if they found themselves needing to apply for disability benefits. The video can be seen at

The Broken of Britain group has been campaigning since summer 2010 to raise awareness of the government’s wider anti-disability policies. The group has consistently drawn attention to disabled people being the target of unjust government rhetoric and sham consultations, tabloid slander and political myths.

It says: “We are now the targets of deep and damaging cuts to disability services that are contained in and symbolised by the Welfare Reform Bill. The Bill disguises cuts and changes to a number of benefits, from housing benefit to Income Support that will punish disabled people.”

Notes for editors

1. Kaliya Franklin and other case studies are available for interview.

2. A high resolution version of the campaign photograph is available on request.

3. For more information, contact Rhydian Fôn James at or 07774021785, or Kaliya Franklin at 07714208602

4. Contribution-related Employment Support Allowance will be restricted to 365 days, meaning that a married claimant would be unable to claim after a year if their spouse works.

5. The Welfare Reform Bill confirms that Disability Living Allowance will be replaced by the Personal Independence Payment which will use unfair assessment and conditions to disqualify 20 per cent of the current DLA caseload.

There is no evidence that supports government’s claims that DLA is “broken” and in need of reform. In fact, most evidence suggests that DLA is an efficient and popular benefit, and this support includes the vast majority of the DWP’s own research.

The inclusion of this benefit change in the Welfare Reform Bill took place before the consultation on DLA reform was completed.

6. Other cuts to disability services not included in the Welfare Reform Bill are:

• Plans to remove security of tenure from social housing tenants, as costly adaptations are a barrier to moving regardless of size of property.
• Many changes to the provision, entitlement to and charges paid for receiving social care and disability services provided by local authorities.
• The Independent Living Fund which provided for the highest level support needs in combination with the local authorities is now to be scrapped without consultation.
• Access to Work reform redefines what it is "reasonable" to expect an employer to provide for disabled staff, meaning it is likely to push many currently employed disabled people out of work and back onto benefits.

7. Disabled people are more likely to live in poverty than any other group in the UK and more likely to be unemployed or in low paid jobs. 60% of those with a work-limiting disability are unemployed, with 25% wanting to work.

Creative Commons Licence
Left Out In The Cold by Kaliya Franklin is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License.
Permissions beyond the scope of this license may be available at


Oya's Daughter said...

Wow, amazing image; brave woman, it was freezing yesterday!

Anonymous said...

Merton council cuts have taken the only independence I had away.

I wish I could write as well as you do.

I want to tell the world that I want to be independent.

I don't want to be scum.

Carl said...

I'll try to get this posted around my Australian networks. Definitely worth getting naked for!

notcrazy said...

the image is ok. However a few things bother me. It looks like a pretty sunny day with lots of blue clouds, so how is that meant to convey 'coldness'?

Again, we are going with the wheelchair thing. There is more to disability than being in a wheelchair, so unfortunately this image does more harm than good in my case because it only strengthens common belief that disabiility=wheelchair.

One person on their own again strenghtens the belief that disabled people are poor and helpless and need picking up (and pushing around, its an attendant wheelchair)

just plays into their hands unfortunately...

(hoping youd rather hear it from someone on this side )

RockHorse said...

I think that the image is stunning! That looks like winter sky to me and Kaliya looks seriously cold! But perhaps notcrazy's comment is worth thinking about for a SERIES of images. 'Left out of the Loop' signifying the deaf/hearing-impaired is one tag-line that springs to mind. Not sure how to portray that beyond something to do with a broken hearing-aid and other people whispering to each other, though. And there MUST be others but I guess it'd depend on people coming up with the concept for each image, people being willing to be the 'model(s)' and having someone to take good 'photos. Step forward, those willing...

But images have to be striking before people take notice and, for better or worse, the wheelchair IS the catch-all symbol for disability. 'Person with stick' still says "Old Age Pensioner" to too many people.

Great campaign, guys! And that image is GREAT!


Anonymous said...

We Lib Dems are helping the disabled by taking away benefits, which are a disincentive to work.

Anonymous said...

Another idiot who refuses to understand what DLA actually does!

Brilliant image. Great campaign. Thanks so much for all this.

Carruthers said...

Please will somebody tell Anon (10 March) that Anon (8 March) was making a political point AGAINST the Lib Dems. I would have thought that this fake post which was too (intentionally) crude for anyone to mistake it for the real thing.

And for the rest, I agree that there is a danger of disabled=wheelchair stereotypes, and that it would make sense to have some more.

RockHorse has one good suggestion. Here's another (well, how good it is you'll have to decide for yourself) - "Nobody listening" - picture of someone in a filthy room sat with their arms wrapped round themselves in obvious distress. We need something to include the often over-looked needs of the mentally ill. Though you might have trouble finding someone who genuinely has serious mental health issues who is also capable of agreeing to this sort of project. It is important that you use genuinely disabled people, or the word "fake" might get attached to the whole thing, which would be disastrous.

But it makes a good start - congrats Kaliya - do I spot an opening for a "Calendar Girls" set of images here?

matthew Occupational Therapist said...

Love the contrast and power of the image - beautiful and thought provoking!